| Platinum | Lazzari Italian Oven |
| Gold | Mazzios Italian Eatery |
| Silver | Lost Pizza Co |
| Bronze | La Bocca Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Brick Oven |
| Top Pick | Fazoli's |
| Top Pick | Mazzio's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pastaria 49 |
| Top Pick | Que 49 Smokehouse |