| Platinum | El Primo Carnitas |
| Gold | Rinconcito Mexicano |
| Silver | Papito's |
| Bronze | Don Jose Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Casa Blanca Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Casa Brava |
| Top Pick | Casa Maya |
| Top Pick | El'Acapulco Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Kandela Grill |
| Top Pick | Ta Molly's |